• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • BLOG
  • Newsletters
  • Reviews
    • Our Reviews
    • Review Us
  • Videos
  • Contact Us
  • WhoWe Are
    • A Message From Mark Costley
    • Meet Our Team
    • Communities We Serve
  • WhatWe Do
    • Advanced Estate Planning
      • Asset Protection
      • Business Succession Planning
      • Charitable Giving
      • Family Foundation
      • Family Limited Partnerships
      • Grantor Retained Annuity Trust
      • Irrevocable Life Insurance Trust
      • Planning For Charitable Gifts
      • Special Needs Planning
    • Counseling Non-Profits
    • Elder Law and Special Needs Planning
    • Estate and Gift Tax Planning
    • Estate Planning
    • Power of Attorney
    • Probate & Trust Administration
    • Process
    • SECURE Act
    • Social Entrepreneurship & Business Law
  • WhyWe Do It
    • Peace Of Mind
  • Resources
    • Caregiving Resources
      • Caregiving Worksheets
      • Our Book
    • Definitions
    • Elder Law Reports
    • Estate Planning Resources
      • Estate Planning Articles
      • Estate Plan Checkup
      • Estate Planning Reports
      • Is Your Estate Plan Outdated?
      • Top 10 Estate Planning Techniques
    • Frequently Asked Questions
      • Elder Law
      • Estate Planning
      • Estate Planning for Parents
      • FAQs for Families Without an Estate Plan
      • Divorce and Your Estate Plan
      • Estate Planning for Women
      • Estate Planning 101
      • Legacy Wealth Planning
      • LGBTQ Estate Planning
      • Nursing Home Planning
      • Spliter
        • Philanthropy and Your Estate Plan
        • Planning for Dementia
        • Probate
        • Serving as Executor
        • Special Needs Planning
        • Tax Avoidance Planning
        • Trust Administration
        • Trust Administration & Probate
        • Social Security Retirement System
        • Will Contests
    • Pre Consultation Form
    • Probate Resources
      • Chapel Hill Probate
      • Raleigh Probate Resources
    • Professional Resources

Clarity Legal Group

Estate Planning Information Center

919-484-0012 Schedule Consultation
Attend a Free Seminar
  • WhoWe Are
    • A Message From Mark Costley
    • Meet Our Team
    • Communities We Serve
  • WhatWe Do
    • Advanced Estate Planning
      • Asset Protection
      • Business Succession Planning
      • Charitable Giving
      • Family Foundation
      • Family Limited Partnerships
      • Grantor Retained Annuity Trust
      • Irrevocable Life Insurance Trust
      • Planning For Charitable Gifts
      • Special Needs Planning
    • Counseling Non-Profits
    • Elder Law and Special Needs Planning
    • Estate and Gift Tax Planning
    • Estate Planning
    • Power of Attorney
    • Probate & Trust Administration
    • Process
    • SECURE Act
    • Social Entrepreneurship & Business Law
  • WhyWe Do It
    • Peace Of Mind
  • Resources
    • Caregiving Resources
      • Caregiving Worksheets
      • Our Book
    • Definitions
    • Elder Law Reports
    • Estate Planning Resources
      • Estate Planning Articles
      • Estate Plan Checkup
      • Estate Planning Reports
      • Is Your Estate Plan Outdated?
      • Top 10 Estate Planning Techniques
    • Frequently Asked Questions
      • Elder Law
      • Estate Planning
      • Estate Planning for Parents
      • FAQs for Families Without an Estate Plan
      • Divorce and Your Estate Plan
      • Estate Planning for Women
      • Estate Planning 101
      • Legacy Wealth Planning
      • LGBTQ Estate Planning
      • Nursing Home Planning
      • Spliter
        • Philanthropy and Your Estate Plan
        • Planning for Dementia
        • Probate
        • Serving as Executor
        • Special Needs Planning
        • Tax Avoidance Planning
        • Trust Administration
        • Trust Administration & Probate
        • Social Security Retirement System
        • Will Contests
    • Pre Consultation Form
    • Probate Resources
      • Chapel Hill Probate
      • Raleigh Probate Resources
    • Professional Resources
Home » BLOG » Estate Planning » Law in the U.S. can be Participatory

Law in the U.S. can be Participatory

Blog Author: Stephen C. Hartnett, J.D., LL.M. (Tax), Director of Education,
American Academy of Estate Planning Attorneys, Inc.

In some countries, like a dictatorship or a true monarchy (not a constitutional monarchy such as the United Kingdom), people do not really participate in making the law. The law is handed down by fiat. In the United States, our laws are enacted by our elected representatives. Sometimes, those laws may be viewed as violating the fundamental rights guaranteed to all of us by our Constitution. That’s when the judiciary may be asked to step in to make an impartial determination as to whether the law violates the fundamental rights embodied by our Constitution. In our system, anyone who is truly harmed by a law may challenge its constitutionality. They can do this by challenging the application of the law in court. Here’s a quick story of how one person participated in changing the law in the United States.

Edith Windsor married her longtime partner, Dr. Thea Spyer, in 2007. Later, when Dr. Spyer died in 2009, the estate filed a federal estate tax return, claiming a marital deduction for the assets going to Ms. Windsor, her spouse under New York law. The IRS denied the deduction based on the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), which prohibited the federal government from recognizing same-sex marriages, even those recognized by a state. The IRS disallowed the marital deduction for assets going to Windsor and claimed, as a result, the estate owed more than $363,000 in federal estate taxes. The estate paid the amount owed and sued for a refund in federal district court, challenging the IRS’ denial of the marital deduction. (Often taxpayers pay a disputed tax and then file suit in federal district court rather than not paying and challenging the amount due in the U.S. Tax Court, which is often viewed as a less favorable venue.) She won at the federal district court. The case was appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals, which affirmed the decision of the district court. Finally, the case ended up at the U.S. Supreme Court, which affirmed the decision of the lower courts.

The U.S. Supreme Court held DOMA was unconstitutional insofar as it denied a benefit (a deduction) to same-sex married couples while granting the same benefit to similarly situated heterosexual couples. Based on the decision in U.S. v. Windsor, same-sex married couples gained equality of treatment under the law by the federal government. The Court did not determine whether same-sex couples had a constitutional right to marry, though they would reach that determination two years later in another case, Obergefell v. Hodges, which built on the Windsor decision.

Ms. Windsor, who demonstrated how an individual in our country can participate in making and shaping the law, died recently. Here is a link to an article in the New York Times about her life and death.

  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Mark Costley
Mark Costley
With more than 30 years’ experience in private practice, Mark Costley has helped hundreds of North Carolinians with estate planning, living trusts, financial law, probate, and trust administration. Mark’s work involves elements of teaching, strategic analysis and planning, documentation, and assisting clients in implementing their plans. He is devoted to providing the best in planning, efficiency, administration, and asset protection.
Mark Costley
Latest posts by Mark Costley (see all)
  • 10 Estate Planning Tips to Help You Create a Successful Plan - July 11, 2023
  • Spousal Elective Share in North Carolina Explained - June 29, 2023
  • What Is a North Carolina NFA Gun Trust? - June 29, 2023

Date: October 1, 2017 Category: Estate Planning, Legal Education

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Clarity Legal Group

Subscribe to Our Blog

Join the Clarity Legal Group® community by subscribing to our blogs addressing estate planning, elder law, asset protection, healthcare planning, special needs planning, charitable giving and more.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Follow Us

Address

Clarity Legal Group
1414 Raleigh Road Suite 445
Chapel Hill, NC 27517
United States (US)
Phone: 919-484-0012

reply@claritylegalgroup.com

Mailing Address
PO Box 2207
Chapel Hill, NC 27515

Exchange West Office Map

Office Hours

Monday9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Tuesday9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Wednesday9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Thursday9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Friday9:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Map

clarity_sidbr_map

Clarity Legal Group is conveniently located in the heart of the Triangle, based in Chapel Hill and proudly serving the state of North Carolina including Durham, Cary, Apex, Pittsboro, Hillsborough, Holly Springs, and Raleigh.

  • About The American Academy
  • Disclaimer
  • Diversity
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • © 2023 American Academy of Estate Planning Attorneys.
    All Rights Reserved.
    Attorney Advertisement
  • Clarity Legal Group footer logo

    Clarity Legal Group is a registered Trademark and trade name for The Mark Costley Law Group, PLLC


    • Read Our 5-Star Client Reviews

"AV® , AV Preeminent® , Martindale-Hubbell DistinguishedSM and Martindale-Hubbell NotableSM are Certification Marks used under license in accordance with the Martindale-Hubbell® certification procedures, standards and policies."

x

Fill out the form below to access to the worksheets and checklists discussed in The Ultimate Caregiver Guide! After submitting this form, you can clic

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.